for Musings & Whiteboard Shots

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

If it has a purpose

I find this to be a very controversial topic. The idea of finding a cure for cancer and other diseases is great. And obviously most people wouldn't want to be tested on, whether it's for medical purposes or something else, unless of course they volunteer (which some do). Animals do not have that luxury because they are animals. You need the human's consent in order to test on them, except for third world countries where the most human testing takes place. But you do not need an animal's consent, and researchers take advantage of that. The recent articles we read in class argue that there are few animal groups that have cognitive abilities, and some (like Koko) can be taught sign language. Another article claims that fish have the same sensory wiring to detect pain. What they don't know is if the animals themselves can understand what they are doing. They would need to do a more deeper analysis, and run more extensive tests. When it comes to finding cures for people, the obvious choice is to test on animals. If it means that this specific medication might be able to significantly help with Parkinson's disease or any other, then go for it and test away. Where I cross the line is the point when pharmaceutical companies test meaningless drugs, or want to produce another type of painkiller only too make more money. That is a waste of time.



1 comment:

  1. I agree with you Anna. If scientist or reaserchers are testing on animals to find a cure for cancer or a disease that is fine. Animals are worthy and do feel pain no matter if some humans think that we are in a higher level than animals. Humans would never be okay with them having to go through all the pain the animals being tested on have to go through. In one of the articles we have read and annotated called a change of heart about animals it explains how animals are actually very smart. Animals can teach us lessons without even knowing it. A gorilla was taught sign language. How amazing is that. All animals mourn for their dead family, friends just like humans. Animals feel all the emotions we do and just to use them to experiment dumb stuff should not be allowed. Only to find cures for cancer and diseases should animal testing be allowed because what else would we use?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.